Flightmed archive for August-2002
FlightWeb Links
----------------------
Flightmed archive for August-2002



[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

ec-135 vs bk 117 (no contest)



I was a flight paramedic for six years at UNC AIR CARE at the University of North Carolina.  I had the pleasure to fly in the A and C model of the BK-117.  I also had the displeasure of working in a EC-135.  The EC-135 is one of the smoothest helicopter that I have flown in.  The Pilots loved it.  
 
The patient care area is very small, very little storage space, very little headroom.  If your are looking for a smooth ride pick the EC-135.  If you want a great helicopter for patient care pick the BK-117c model.  You can actually have color weather radar and a moving map display.  The EC-135 also has some weight load issues.  An EC-135 was sent to our program for the flight crew to see if it would work with our patient profile.  Almost all of the pediatric and adult flight team members stated that the aircraft was to small and that we would have problems with ergonomics.  We had start using the Stryker stretcher on the BK-117c and it had eliminated almost all of our back problems.  We were told that if we did not think the EC-135 would work, we would not get it.  Well, an EC-135 showed up, surprise, surprise.   There were hard feelings about the aircraft.  We nolonger had a nightsun, color weather radar, and our beloved stryker stretcher.  Before signing up for a EC-135 ask if we put color radar, and nightsun what would our actual payload be with 2 hours of fuel.  UNC had a five year contact for the EC-135 and they have switched to a non customized BK-117 years before the contract ran out?????????????????  I am sure that the EC-135 is great for programs that flew astar''s or BO 105.  I flew on a astar for three years.  I am glad that UNC is returning to the BK-117 and maybe they might think about the EC-145.  It looks good on paper.  Good luck on your decision and I hope you include everyone on the flight team in the interior design, you will come out with a better aircraft. 
 
Ps: I did not take the air care challenge
 
 
Scott Morgan, EMT-P

[ Home | Archive | Classifieds | Links | Resources | White Pages ]
line picture
© 2000 -- Website created by Rollie Parrish | Credits | Last modified: 08/31/02