 
|
|
|
ok.... here's my $0.02 on simultaneous dispatch:
Interesting idea....... but if the helicopter arrives to the scene first: who sets up the LZ for them???
remember: SAFETY FIRST!
Jeremy Hawk <akulahawk@earthlink.net> wrote:
Just gotta throw in my (dwindling) $0.02...
I find it really hard to believe that TRANSPORT times are that fast
in favor of the ground ambulance. Either the aircraft is that slow,
or you're looking at different data points.
In a county where I used to work, there are simultaneous dispatch
areas for ground and air providers. This means that when there is ANY
call in these areas, BOTH are dispatched at the same time. Once the
helicopter is in the air, it will catch and pass the ambulance at
about 7-10 miles from the base, and often is first on scene in those
areas. If the patient needs to be flown out, even assuming the ground
and air providers arrive at the same time) the helicopter is still
running, and ready to fly really quickly. From those simultaneous
dispatch areas, flight time to a Level 1 or 2 Trauma Center is about
15 minutes. Contrast that to about 10 minutes or so for a ground
ambulance to reach ANY hospital, and about 30 minutes to reach the
closest Trauma Center.
Oh, and scene times are about the same regardless of air/ground. Both
air and ground providers are basically equally fast.
So... try this one: look at ACTUAL scene times for both air and
ground crews, and the elapsed time from their patient contact to
arrival at the hospital. Then account for some variables, such as
whether or not the helicopter is shut down while on scene. That will
lengthen times. If all other things are equal, then there has to be
some "soul searchng" to be done to determine when (elapsed time wise)
the aircaft should be alerted or actually dispatched on calls.
I would suspect that if a ground trip for a critical patient is about
30 minutes, flying the patient would start making more sense.
Assuming, of course, that a round trip by helicopter would take about
30 minutes from dispatch. I'd probably put the helicopter on alert if
I was that far out... and activate (if not done automatically) upon
recognition of a critical patient.
Real World Example:
When I was (briefly) working in San Joaquin county, I had a call that
took us about 30 minutes to get to. A helicopter was automatically
dispatched when we were, and had to come from Sacramento. They
started from about 50 air miles from the scene, and beat us on scene
by about 5 minutes or so. The only thing that slowed them down was
having to choose an appropriate LZ... 100m from the patient, across a
soft field... It would have taken us 45-60 minutes to transport this
patient from the scene to the 'appropriate' hospital, whereas the
helicopter took only about 20 minutes from loading the patient...
As many others have said, before embarking on this fact-finding
mission, design your study to account for the inherent differences
between air and ground transport. Make it compare apples to apples,
in a thoughtful and meaningful way. Then report back or publish your
study and we all will learn from you.
And good luck in School!
>TO: Flightmed group:
>From: Mark Seeloff
>Subject: Transport Time (School assignment)
>
>I would like to introduce myself to the group. I am nursing student
>at the University of Buffalo. I am also a career
>firefighter/paramedic with the City of Lockport Fire Department, New
>York. I am also a hospital corpsmen(USNR) for the 3 /25 Marine
>company out of Buffalo, New York. I have experience with Mercy
>flight (ground crew) and helicopter evacuation with the marines.I am
>interested in becoming a flight nurse after college. I have a
>question for the group that has to do with transport time.
>
>My fire department runs the local ambulance service and there is a
>local air ambulance. I researched the department records for
>transport time for traumas for the past 3 years. I compared the
>transport time from leaving the scene to on scene at the local
>trauma center both by our ground transport vs air transport. Our
>ground time for transport was 30 minutes to the trauma center. The
>air transport time was 40 minutes. My department is ACLS,PALS and
>BTLS certified. My question is Should we wait the 10 minutes for the
>air transport or should we by pass the air transport for the faster
>time to the trauma center ? Considering the golden hour but the
>local protocol states that the air transport if available be used.
>We are certified in ACLS,PALS, and BTLS but we do not have all the
>fancy machines that is carried on the helicopter. I would appreciate
>your inputs on this subject. Thanks
>
>
>
>
>Mark Seeloff
>Student Nurse
>University of Buffalo
>docmseeloff@hotmail.com
--
___________________________
Jeremy M. Hawk, BS, EMT-P
Just an example, from the real world, that demonstrates the point.
_______________________________________________
Flightmed mailing list
To unsubscribe or change your email address, go to http://www.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/flightmed